Almost three years have passed since the Autoweek garage obtained a long-term Honda Fit, and two years after its departure, I feel the same as I did then: practical B-class car, some hints of sportiness, but ultimately it's missing something.
Shopping this class today, I'm looking much more seriously at Ford's hip little Fiesta or Chevrolet's fun-to-drive Sonic. The Fit doesn't match the Ford in the looks department, and based on a brief back-to-back test drive I had in May, it doesn't match the Sonic's relative punch.
What it does do is haul a surprising amount of cargo, rev high and shift well through its five-speed manual gearbox. But our long-standing complaint of no sixth gear remains an issue, as the engine spins high, almost to 4,000 rpm, at freeway speeds and you tire quickly of the accompanying buzz.
It's hard to point a finger at one specific thing, but a drive in the Fit still makes me feel as though there is just something not quite spot-on about the overall experience. Maybe it's the slightly too-light-to-the-touch feel that comes through the controls, and/or maybe it's the road and wind noise, and the sometimes rattly ride. It doesn't help my perception that there are now more fuel-efficient and better-looking (to my eyes, anyway) competitors available. The pricing among the B-class contenders is so close that if you test-drive a Fit, you absolutely must test its rivals.
In a past life, I worked for a company producing a Fit competitor, and occasionally the company would arrange back-to-back drives with the little Honda and other B-car competitors such as the Toyota Yaris and the Nissan Versa. I never failed to come away from the experience thinking that the Fit was the hands-down winner in the category, and that my employer would be wise to not include it in further comparison tests.
A few years later, my opinion hasn't changed. I still think the Honda Fit is the car to beat in the B-segment. The engine feels surprisingly strong, the gearbox and shifter are a delight to use and outward visibility is near perfect.
As important as the driving dynamics, upon entering the Honda Fit, you're treated to an automotive magic show. Like a carnival fun house, the Fit feels three times larger on the inside than seems possible given its exterior dimensions. Headroom? Tons for this six-footer. Ditto the legroom. Even rear-seat space was fine for two kids in car seats. Sure, they could kick the back of the front seats, but they can do that in a Honda Odyssey.
Just for grins, we crammed the 100-pound dog in the cargo area to see what would happen. He gave us a chagrined glance, then turned around three times and lay down--with the hatch closed. Try that with any of the Fit's competitors; not going to happen.
And, to top off the interior spectacle, Honda includes its Magic Seats in the Fit package, allowing the bottom cushion of the rear seats to fold up against the seatback. Coupled with the low floor and the tall roof, the feat allows taller cargo to fit upright in the middle of the car. The seats also fold flat for maximum storage through the hatch.
For me, complaints about the Honda Fit are minor. The driver's seat could use more bottom cushion and better adjustability. The intermittent wiper could use an adjustable delay. The rear drum brakes should be exorcised from the automotive world, and the power steering is a touch overboosted at highway speeds.
As for the lack of a sixth gear, I'm not sure how useful it would be given the Fit's torque output. The car is a city commuter with a flexible powertrain and good in-town gas mileage. If you have to hit the highway, just pretend it's Italian.
I spent a lot of time in our old long-termer, and it was actually a fun little car to drive. The five-speed is like a joystick, and the steering has plenty of response. I like the relatively light weight, tight chassis and reasonable price.
I do think Honda has been passed by in this segment, as it seems the fuel economy and aesthetics just are not what they should be. The interior looks and feels a bit inexpensive, the seats are not comfortable to my taste and it's rather loud. Conversely, you can put a ton of stuff in Fits, and I vividly recall loading one up for holiday duty in 2008.
Still, the easy clutch and the high-revving engine make for eager and agreeable driving for enthusiasts. I had a good time in this car.
The elements that made our long-term Honda Fit (the Deerslayer!) an excellent daily driver are still here--loads of interior room, a smooth and robust powertrain with an easy-to-work five-speed manual (this clutch-and-stick combo is perfect for teaching the manual arts to new drivers), and a solid chassis. And being a southpaw, I take special delight in the cupholder on the left edge of the dashboard--even if putting something in the holder blocks the air vent.
A weekend with the Fit also brings out areas where this car is being challenged by the competition. There is plenty of road noise that gets into the cabin, for starters. Much of that comes from the large expanse of glass in the car, which is not a great sound barrier. Also, there doesn't seem to be that much sound-deadening material in the floor, likely a tactic to keep the car's weight lower.
For short-to-medium drives, the contoured foam in the Fit's driver's seat holds up well. But you'll want a break, and you'll be wishing for more support, if your trips stretch beyond three hours.
The forte of the Fit is its ability to swallow great amounts of cargo, more than you can image by just looking at the outside of the car. The Fit's flip-fold rear seat is a model of engineering simplicity. And it's nice to be able to easily roll into a parking space that's be squished because of a badly parked minivan in the next space over.
